Chapter 8 : Tuesday morning at eight forty, Mara pulled into the Willow Bend members' row parking lot and parked in the second spot from the door.
Her father's truck was already there.
He was standing by the porte-cochère with a hat in his hands, wearing the sport coat he'd worn to Daniel's wedding and a plain shirt. He had a manila envelope under his arm. He looked older than he had at the beginning of the summer, which was not something she'd noticed until now, standing across the lot.
"You ready?" he said.
"No," she said. "You?"
"No."
They walked in together.
Renata Cole was at the front desk with a leather folder under her arm. She nodded at Mara. She looked at Robert Ellison Senior with a very slight, almost imperceptible, surprise that she did not permit to reach her face.
"Mr. Ellison," she said.
"Renata," he said. "I've got some paper for Mr. Whitfield."
"He's in the boardroom."
They walked down the hallway past the plaque. Her father stopped in front of it. He looked at it for a moment — the founding row, the lacquered brass, the neat engraved lines, the row where it read ROBERT J. ELLISON, and under it, the smaller row where it read DANIEL R. ELLISON — and he did not say anything, and Mara did not say anything, and they walked on.
In the boardroom, Finton Whitfield was in his chair. Thomas Ashby was at the far end. Renata stood at the side. Serena Downing sat by the door with the minutes book open. There was one empty chair at the middle of the table, and one empty chair at the far end — the chair where Hollis Ellison was supposed to sit — and one more empty chair that had been pulled over to the side of the table by Renata, which Mara understood, when she looked at it, had been pulled over for her father.
"Mr. Ellison," Whitfield said, standing.
"Mr. Whitfield."
"You're here with new information."
"I'm here," her father said, "to say what I should have said eleven weeks ago."
He put the manila envelope on the table and sat down. He did not need to be told where.
Whitfield opened the envelope and pulled out three sheets of paper. A handwritten note in ballpoint, on a lined pad from the pharmacy, with a date and a time at the top. A photograph of the same note, printed on photo paper. And a single sheet of bank statements that had been stapled to the back, printed from the credit union's website Sunday night, showing the two hundred and forty dollars paid to Willow Bend Country Club, out of Mara Ellison's own checking account, on two dates, matching the two paid quarters.
Her father talked for six minutes. He did not cry. He talked in the flat way he talked, and Whitfield let him finish, and when he was done, Whitfield turned to Ashby and said, "Mr. Ashby."
Ashby said, "The ID on the retype is his?"
Her father answered. "R.ELLISO is my login. It has been my login since 1987. Hollis sat on my porch Thursday at two-fifteen and asked for it. I gave it to him. I did not know what he was going to do with it. That is the truth and it is in the note he's holding and I'll say it under oath if I have to."
Ashby looked at Whitfield.
"Then we know who made the altered copy," Ashby said. "Or we know who used whose login to make it. Which for this board's purposes is the same thing."
Whitfield nodded. He looked at Renata.
"Ms. Cole."
Renata opened the leather folder and took out a single sheet of paper — the original void-transfer form — and laid it flat in the middle of the table, between the two empty chairs.
"Also," Renata said, "the membership office's IT review was completed last night by an outside contractor at my request. The audit log for the shared drive shows the retyped copy was created Friday at 4:31 pm from the workstation in the phone room behind the front desk."
"Whose badge opens that room?" Whitfield said.
"Two badges," Renata said. "Mine and Mr. Ellison's."
Whitfield was quiet for a moment.
"Then Mr. Ellison made the copy," he said, "using his brother's dormant login, from the phone room, on Friday afternoon, after lunch service, before we called him about the form. Mr. Ashby, do you have any objection to that finding?"
"I do not."
"Ms. Downing, is that in the minutes?"
"It is, sir."
Whitfield wrote something down. He looked at Mara. He looked at her father. He looked at the empty chairs.
"Then the board's finding is this," he said. "Mr. Hollis Ellison will be suspended from the membership board for the remainder of the year, effective the day before yesterday. He will be removed from the greens committee and the hospitality committee. The board will open a formal inquiry into every void, transfer, and credit reassignment he has filed or signed in the past five years. The board will retain outside counsel to review the results of that inquiry and to advise on any further action it recommends, including referral to the county if the pattern supports it. Ms. Ellison's card is restored, her seat is active, and the credit on her account has been refunded in full, with interest at the club's standard rate for the eleven weeks it was held. The board will issue a written statement to the membership at the end of the review, and it will include the finding that a member of the board used another member's login to alter a document of record. Mr. Ellison Senior will be named as a cooperating witness, not as a subject, and the board will recommend that his daughter?" — he looked at Mara — "Ms. Ellison, is that correct?"
"His daughter is Mara," her father said.
"Ms. Ellison's account status will be corrected on the records going forward, including the anniversary book, and her brother's name will remain on the plaque, and I will personally recommend that the board add a second plaque in the lounge for the members who served on the summer staff as kids. Including Daniel. I have been wanting to do that for six years. This is as good a reason as any."
Whitfield closed the folder.
"That's the meeting," he said.
===
They walked out together. Her father carried the empty manila envelope under his arm. It was misting, a warm small rain that did not make it to the pavement, and the parking lot smelled like cut grass and asphalt.
At his truck, her father stopped.
"Mara," he said. "I want to tell you something. And then I want to go home."
"Okay."
"I was going to say I should have told you earlier," he said. "But I already said that. And it's not what I want to tell you. What I want to tell you is that it's your seat. It was your brother's seat, and now it's your seat, and I don't want it in my name again. I want it in yours. If they ask you to put it back in mine because I'm the oldest living Ellison, you say no. You say it's your seat, and your brother's before it was yours, and you don't know when it's going to be somebody else's after you. That's what I want to tell you."
"Okay."
"I want to say one more thing."
"Okay."
"The day he hit you," her father said. "When Susan called Brenda and Brenda called me and told me what the family was saying, I sat on my porch and I picked up the phone to call you, and I did not call you because Hollis had been telling me for eight weeks that you knew." He looked at the parking lot. "You didn't know. I know that now. I really did not know that until yesterday."
"I know, Dad."
"I'm going to sit with that for a while," he said. "I'm going to sit with it for a long time. But I want to say one thing out loud and you can do whatever you want with it."
"Okay."
"Daniel would have wanted you in that room," her father said. "Not me. You."
He put the envelope in the passenger seat of the truck and got in and started the engine, and rolled down the window and said, "Come to dinner Sunday. Bring nothing. I'll cook."
"Okay."
He drove out past the gate.
===
Mara sat in her car for a while in the members' row. The mist had stopped. The lot was filling, because the Tuesday men's league teed off at nine, and cars were pulling in with golf bags and Sunday-afternoon-summer attitudes. A valet in a white shirt waved at her as he went by, and she waved back, and did not know if he had been working Sunday or not.
She got out of the car.
She walked back into the clubhouse.
Renata was at the front desk, standing with the desk clerk, going over something on a clipboard. She looked up.
"Ms. Ellison."
"Renata," Mara said. "I want to sign the anniversary book."
Renata looked at her for a moment. Then she said, "It's in the lounge. On the low table by the plaque."
The anniversary book was a long leather volume on a small marble-topped table in the members' lounge, under the newer plaque the club had hung in the nineties, and beside the older plaque that went back to the founding years. Every year the club asked members to sign it in the summer. There were 162 signatures in it so far for this year, in every kind of handwriting.
Mara took the pen from the well beside it and opened to the next blank line and wrote:
*Mara J. Ellison — in memory of Daniel R. Ellison*
She put the pen down.
She stood there for a moment, and looked at her brother's name on the plaque, and did not say anything to it, because there was nothing to say that she hadn't said already or would say again somewhere else. Then she walked to the grill room. The room was empty at 9:20 on a Tuesday morning — the men's league hadn't come through yet — and the bussers were setting tables for lunch, working the long tables at the far end. The corner table by the tall windows was set with a single setting, silverware laid beside a checkered cloth, water glass in its place. Nobody was going to sit at it for lunch — she could see that from the way only one setting was laid — but it was not cleared either, and nobody had taken the chair away.
Mara did not sit down at it.
She stood at the doorway for a moment and looked at it as long as she wanted to, which was the first time in two years she had stood in that room and looked at anything as long as she wanted to, and then she turned around and walked out through the hall and out the front door and got back into her car and drove to work, and it was 9:34 on a Tuesday, and the windows in the grill room behind her were tight against the sun.
Advertisement
All 8 chapters
- 1The palm landed before the words did.
- 2The parking lot at Willow Bend was laid out like everything else about the club — deliberately. There was the members' row, shaded, close to the door, with brass plaques for the old families. There was the guests' row, in the sun. And the
- 3Serena Downing's email arrived at 4:12. Mara opened it at the red light at the corner of Route 12 and Sunset Boulevard and had to pull into the church parking lot on the far side to actually read it, because there was an attachment, and t
- 4She called Dee.
- 5There was a second signature. There was a president who had known it for eleven weeks. There was a form in the board copy with a field retyped and a form in the membership office with the field intact. There was a chit in the plastic bin
- 6By nine-forty she was outside on the brick path between the clubhouse and the parking lot, standing under the shade of the porte-cochère with Dee beside her and both of them not saying anything.
- 7She did not call her father from the break room. She finished her shift. She drove home. She fed the cat that wasn't really hers — the one that had adopted the duplex — and she sat at her kitchen table with her laptop open and the screens
- 8Tuesday morning at eight forty, Mara pulled into the Willow Bend members' row parking lot and parked in the second spot from the door.





