Chapter 2 : The parking lot at Willow Bend was laid out like everything else about the club — deliberately. There was the members' row, shaded, close to the door, with brass plaques for the old families. There was the guests' row, in the sun. And the
Mara had parked in the guests' row. She always did. Three years of coming there and she'd never once put the car in the members' row, even though the receptionist at the gate had finally stopped asking and just waved her through. She'd told herself it was habit. She knew it was because if she parked in the members' row, Hollis would see it, and there would be a conversation.
She sat in the car with the engine off and the AC not running and the July sun turning the cabin into a slow oven, and she replayed the plastic chit in Renata Cole's hand and the way the room had gone quiet and the way the two members at her own table had turned their chairs.
She didn't cry. She waited for it. It didn't come.
Her phone rang.
"Hey," she said.
"Mara." A pause. "It's Dee." Daniel's widow — her sister-in-law, if you could call it that, since she'd only been married to Daniel for eleven months — was named Deirdre, but nobody had called her that in years.
"Hey, Dee."
"Someone from the club called your dad," Dee said. "Hollis's wife called Susan, and Susan called your dad, and your dad called me, and I am telling you right now I am not calling you to yell at you, I'm calling you because your dad is about to."
"Yeah."
"Mara. What the hell happened?"
So she told her. Standing in the parking lot, one hand on the hot black hood of the car so the metal could burn her palm and give her something else to feel while she talked. The tray. The greeting. The front desk. The chit. The slap — she told Dee about the slap the way you report a fact, no adjectives, and Dee went quiet on the other end for a long stretch.
"You need to call him," Dee said finally. "You need to call him before he hears it from Hollis's version."
"I know."
"And Mara — listen. Whatever's in the file, whatever the second signature is — you make them show you the paper. You don't accept any version anybody tells you. You make them show you the paper." Dee had worked front-desk and then member services for four years before Daniel died. She knew how the club ran. She'd left the year he passed. "They always have the paper. They just don't always show it."
"Yeah."
"Call your dad."
"Okay."
She called her father from the Wendy's parking lot six miles out of town, because she was not going to do it with the club still in her rearview mirror.
Robert Ellison Senior, seventy-two, retired high school shop teacher, had remarried nine years ago and moved to a double-wide on four acres east of town where he kept a garden and a small tractor and did not, as a rule, get involved in Ellison family politics. He had been, for the past two years, ignoring a great deal of Hollis Ellison on the subject of the club. Mara had heard the version he'd been sold: that the club had quietly revoked Daniel's family seat after the funeral, that Hollis had been "fighting to keep it in the family," that Mara's ongoing presence at Willow Bend was a matter of Hollis's intercession.
She had believed it, too. Everyone had. That was the part she was still working on.
"Mara," her father said, instead of hello. "What did you do."
She told him.
There was a long silence. She heard the sound of a screen door, and then the creak of the porch swing. He was going outside. He always went outside.
"I don't know what to say," he said, after a while.
"Then don't say anything."
"Mara."
"Dad, I'm not asking."
"Mara, if you'd just said something to him. If you'd just let him know before you walked in there with the card—"
"Dad. I found out about the card from the front desk this morning. I found out the club hadn't revoked my seat from the front desk this morning. Nine oh two. Do you understand what I'm saying?"
Another long silence.
"Your uncle says he told you months ago that seat was gone. That he told the whole family. That he told you to your face. That's what Susan called to say." His voice had gone careful, which was worse than angry, because careful meant he was already halfway to believing it.
"He never told me that," Mara said. "Not once. Not to my face, not on the phone. I found out from the club that the form existed. Today."
"Well," her father said, "I don't know how we square that."
The porch swing creaked.
"Dad," Mara said. "There's a void-transfer form in the office. On my membership. It was filed eleven weeks ago. It has Hollis's signature on it. And it has a second signature on it that isn't his. Renata Cole is keeping the chit he initialed. I have a voicemail on my phone right now from the front desk saying Mr. Whitfield wants to see my paperwork before six. I am telling you this because you are going to hear it from Hollis in his version, and I want you to have heard it in mine first. That's all. That's what I'm asking. Just hear it in mine first."
Her father said nothing.
She said, "I'll text you when I know more."
She hung up.
Then she sat in the Wendy's parking lot for a while and watched a teenager in a red vest carry a trash bag around the lot and thought about the fact that she was going to have to speak to the club president, Finton Whitfield — a man she had met exactly twice, both times at the club Christmas party, once holding a glass of wine and once holding the door for her — before six o'clock this evening, with the paper, with whatever the second signature said, and no lawyer and no rehearsal and no idea whose hand it was.
Her phone buzzed again. A text from an unknown number.
*Ms. Ellison. This is Serena Downing, I'm the membership services clerk. Renata asked me to be the one to reach out to you because she's going into a meeting with Mr. Whitfield this afternoon. I used to work with your brother on the cart staff. Can I call you? There's something else.*
Mara typed: *yes.*
The phone rang before she'd finished letting her thumb off the screen.
Serena Downing was young — Mara remembered the voice from the voicemail at the front desk, nervous, slightly rushed. She did not sound nervous now. She sounded like someone who had made a decision.
"Ms. Ellison, I'm going to tell you what I know and I need you to understand that I might get fired for it."
"Okay."
"The void-transfer form — the one with your uncle's signature on it — I'm the one who filed it. Eleven weeks ago. I filed it because he brought it to me in an envelope with his signature on it and told me it was a family decision, that your brother's seat was being closed out of the family name because you weren't in the blood Ellison line, only the married-in line. That's not a rule. There's no such rule in the bylaws. But I didn't know that then. I filed it."
Mara waited.
"Two weeks later the same envelope came back to me from the membership office with a second signature on it." Serena stopped. "Ms. Ellison, the second signature is not a member's. It's initials. Two letters, in the field where the member services office has to counter-approve a void. I filed it as a regular void because I hadn't been trained on the counter-approval process yet, and it went through. That's on me. But I need you to know that the initials are not mine."
"Whose are they?"
"I don't know. I never met the person. But I can tell you one thing." Serena's voice dropped. "Mr. Whitfield has a copy of the form in his office, and so does the board, and so does the membership office. Three copies. Standard for any void."
"And?"
"And when I printed my copy last Friday to put in the file, I noticed the second signature on it." A long breath. "Ms. Ellison, the version the board has doesn't have the second signature. The version in the membership office doesn't either. Only Mr. Whitfield's copy and mine."
Mara stood very still in the Wendy's parking lot.
"You're saying someone made two different versions," she said.
"I'm saying somebody retyped the form," Serena said. "The one I printed Friday has a signature line for the counter-approval. The one the board has doesn't. So either somebody retyped it after the second signature was added, or the form was designed so that only the club president would see it. I don't know which. I do know I printed mine off the membership office's shared drive Friday afternoon, and the board's copy is dated eleven weeks ago."
"Do you still have your copy?"
"Yes."
"Can you make a copy of your copy?"
A pause. "Ms. Ellison, if I do that, I want you to know I'm doing it because your brother Danny was kind to me when I was nineteen and stupid. Not because I think you're going to win."
"Okay."
"There's also something else." Serena's voice had gone quieter again. "You asked me once, when you came in for the card, about the dues. You asked if the club had ever received your two quarters from your checking account."
"Yes."
"I didn't answer you the way I should have. The dues payment posted. It posted three weeks ago, from a personal account. But it was posted against your brother's old member number. Not your new one."
Mara closed her eyes.
"Why would it post against Danny's number?"
"Because that's the number that was in the file when the payment was applied," Serena said. "Because when a seat is voided, the club system reassigns the dues to the last active number. The last active number was your brother's. So the club took your money and applied it to a membership that was supposed to be gone."
"Where did the money go?"
"Into the club's general dues account. Under your brother's number."
"So the club accepted two hundred and some odd dollars a quarter for a seat that was, in the system, already voided."
"Used," Serena said. "Yes."
Mara stood in the parking lot and let the sun bake the back of her neck and thought about what that meant and got about halfway there.
"Serena," she said. "If the seat was voided, and the dues were being paid against Danny's old number, and the number wasn't attached to anything — where's the credit supposed to have gone?"
"The credit should have been refunded to the payer when the void posted," Serena said. "That's in the procedures manual. It wasn't refunded. It's been sitting in an unapplied-credit line for eleven weeks."
"Whose account is the unapplied credit sitting under?"
Serena's answer took a long time to come.
"Your uncle's," she said. "The credits apply to whoever closed the account. Standard procedure. When a family member files a void on a seat, the unapplied credits route to the filer pending the family's reclaim. It was supposed to be refunded to you. It wasn't. It's been applied to Hollis Ellison's quarterly dues for two quarters."
Mara did not say anything for a while.
"Ms. Ellison?" Serena said. "Are you there?"
"I'm here."
"I want you to know I'm calling you from my car. I'm outside the club. I'm not going back inside today. I'll send you the copy of my form by email this afternoon, before Mr. Whitfield meets with you. I want you to have it."
"Thank you."
"Don't thank me yet," Serena said. "I have to see how this plays out. I've got student loans."
She hung up.
Mara sat back down in her car — she had gotten out and she didn't remember getting out; she was now standing by the open door with the sun on her — and she turned the key and let the AC roar and leaned her head against the seat and let the cold hit her face. She put her hand in her pocket and felt the phone.
Two quarters of dues.
Two hundred and some odd dollars a quarter, paid from her own checking account.
Applied to Hollis Ellison's quarterly dues for two quarters.
===
Advertisement
All 8 chapters
- 1The palm landed before the words did.
- 2The parking lot at Willow Bend was laid out like everything else about the club — deliberately. There was the members' row, shaded, close to the door, with brass plaques for the old families. There was the guests' row, in the sun. And the
- 3Serena Downing's email arrived at 4:12. Mara opened it at the red light at the corner of Route 12 and Sunset Boulevard and had to pull into the church parking lot on the far side to actually read it, because there was an attachment, and t
- 4She called Dee.
- 5There was a second signature. There was a president who had known it for eleven weeks. There was a form in the board copy with a field retyped and a form in the membership office with the field intact. There was a chit in the plastic bin
- 6By nine-forty she was outside on the brick path between the clubhouse and the parking lot, standing under the shade of the porte-cochère with Dee beside her and both of them not saying anything.
- 7She did not call her father from the break room. She finished her shift. She drove home. She fed the cat that wasn't really hers — the one that had adopted the duplex — and she sat at her kitchen table with her laptop open and the screens
- 8Tuesday morning at eight forty, Mara pulled into the Willow Bend members' row parking lot and parked in the second spot from the door.





