Chapter 4 : She called Dee.
Dee said yes before Mara could finish the sentence. Dee had a specific talent: she had worked member services at Willow Bend for four years, she had watched Hollis Ellison operate from the inside, and she had, since Daniel died, made a quiet project of never attending anything at that club again. She had not been inside the building since the funeral reception. She had told Mara once that she'd go back when she had a reason to go back.
At 6:34 Dee pulled up to Mara's duplex in a ten-year-old Honda and got out wearing a black blazer over jeans — the exact uniform she'd worn to member services — with a leather portfolio under one arm.
"You ready?" Dee said.
"No."
"Good," Dee said. "Being ready is for people who know what's coming."
They drove in separate cars. It was not discussed. Mara knew very well why: if the meeting went badly, Dee wanted to be able to leave without depending on Mara, and Mara wanted the same. They parked in the guests' row on purpose. Two cars, side by side, in the lot for people who weren't sure they got to be here.
The club at 6:40 on a Sunday evening was a different animal than the club at Sunday lunch. The grill room was dark and set for the next day's service; the clubhouse lights in the hallway were on but turned down; the front desk had a single clerk behind it, and that clerk was not Serena Downing. A woman in a navy pantsuit with a small pin that said *MEMBERSHIP SERVICES* looked up and nodded them past — down the hallway, past the lounge, to the far end where the boardroom was.
Finton Whitfield was in the boardroom. He was a small, spare man in his late sixties with white hair cut short and a bow tie, which he wore at all times of day, and he had a reputation at Willow Bend that could be summarized as: he had never raised his voice in forty years on the board, and he had never once been overruled.
He stood when they came in. So did Renata, who was at the side of the table. So did Serena Downing, who was sitting very straight in a chair by the door with her hands folded on her knees.
"Ms. Ellison," Whitfield said. "Ms. Downing tells me you have some paper."
"Yes, sir."
"Please, sit."
She sat. Dee sat beside her. Dee put the leather portfolio down on the table and opened it and clicked the pen that she'd brought.
Whitfield looked at the portfolio. Then he looked at Renata. Then he looked at Mara.
"I understand your uncle struck you at lunch today," he said.
"He did."
"Do you want to press charges?"
Mara was silent for a moment.
"I want," she said, "to see the form."
Whitfield nodded once. He reached into a leather folder on the table and took out a single sheet of paper and laid it flat.
It was the void-transfer form. Not a copy. The original. She could see the club seal embossed in the corner. She could see Hollis's signature. And below it, the counter-approval initials.
*T.A.*
Same hand. Blue ink. Same weight of line.
"Ms. Ellison," Whitfield said. "Before you ask — I know the initials. I've known for eleven weeks. I have been waiting for a reason to bring this before the board that would not tear this club apart in the middle of a Sunday lunch. Your uncle gave me a reason today."
"Whose initials?" Mara said.
"Thomas Ashby," Whitfield said.
The name went through the room. Renata did not react. Serena did, slightly — a small movement of her shoulders, a settling back into her chair. Dee wrote the name down in her notebook.
Mara had heard the name once. Once, at a club Christmas party three years ago, when somebody had motioned across the room at a tall, weathered man with a golf-tan and said, *that's Tom Ashby, he's the one with the handicap that's been going down for forty years* — one of those names that existed only inside the club, the way certain last names exist only inside towns.
"Mr. Ashby," Whitfield said, "is on the membership board. He has been on the membership board for nineteen years. He is not here tonight because he is at his daughter's wedding in Richmond. He will be here tomorrow morning at nine. On Friday, he signed the counter-approval on the void on your seat. Do you know why?"
"No."
"Because I asked him to."
Dee stopped writing.
"I asked him to counter-approve the void," Whitfield said, "because eleven weeks ago, your uncle brought me a form to sign and I refused to sign it. The form as it came to me had a blank counter-approval field. I told him I would not approve a family seat void that had an unapplied credit sitting on it. I told him the credit had to be refunded first, or the void would not post. I told him that three times — once in the boardroom, twice in writing. He told me each time that the credit had already been refunded, and that he had a receipt."
"Do you have the receipt?" Dee said.
Whitfield looked at her.
"I have this," he said, and took a second sheet of paper out of the folder.
It was a single-page membership-office printout, computer generated, dated the Friday after the void was filed. It showed the account activity on the Ellison family seat for the previous six months. Line by line. Initiation fees, monthly dues, quarterly dues, an assessment for the new cart path, the standard service charges. Then, below, a single line marked *UNAPPLIED CREDIT — REFUND — PAYEE: MARA J. ELLISON.* A date. A check number. And in the *reconciled* column, blank.
Reconciled: blank.
The refund had never gone out.
"Where did it go?" Mara said quietly.
"Where your uncle sent it," Whitfield said. "As an applied credit on his own family account, under the standard filer-pending-reclaim procedure. He applied it as a credit against his own quarterly dues for two quarters. Then, when I asked him why he'd done that, he told me that the money had come from the family budget, not from you. That your late brother's seat had been paying quarterly out of a family account for years, and that your payments were just you reimbursing the family."
Dee's pen stopped. She looked at Mara.
"Did you reimburse the family?" Whitfield said.
"No," Mara said. "I paid the club directly. From my checking account. Two hundred and forty dollars a quarter. Two quarters. The receipts are in my online banking."
Whitfield nodded.
"Then your uncle has been telling the club a story about the money," he said, "and the club has been repeating it back to itself, and nobody has checked the paper until today. Ms. Downing," he said, turning, "you filed the void as a regular void. Is that correct?"
"Yes, sir," Serena said. "I hadn't been trained on the counter-approval process yet. I filed it as a regular void, and it should have been returned to me for counter-approval, but it wasn't, because Mr. Ashby signed it Friday and sent it straight through to the membership office with a note."
"And why did he sign it Friday?" Whitfield said. "Because Renata called him Friday, after she pulled the file. After she pulled the file because Ms. Ellison came in Friday morning to pick up a member card she should not have been able to pick up, and the desk printed it, and Renata went looking for a reason that a card would print for a seat that the board's records say is voided."
He tapped the board's copy of the form with one finger.
"The board's copy," he said, "was retyped. Someone in the membership office retyped this form after Mr. Ashby signed the original. We don't know who yet. We are looking into it. But we know it happened, because the original has Mr. Ashby's initials, and the board's copy has a blank field, and the two are otherwise identical down to the comma spacing."
"How did you find out about the second signature?" Mara said.
"Renata Cole told me," Whitfield said. "This afternoon. On the phone. Before lunch service was even fully over. She was in a very difficult position. She had a board member's signature on a form, and she had a member who had just been struck in her dining room by the same board member, and she had the paper in front of her, and she decided to call me. I am grateful that she did."
Mara looked at Renata. Renata looked back at her without any particular expression. Renata said, "The grill room is my responsibility. The slap happened in my grill room. That is the part I am sorry about."
"Ms. Ellison," Whitfield said. "I am going to tell you what the club can and cannot do, tonight."
"Okay."
"The club cannot un-slap you. That happened. You may press charges with the county, and if you do, the club will not oppose you. Renata has already written up an incident report. I will sign it. The board will not stand in the way of a criminal charge."
"Okay."
"The club can and will restore your card effective this morning. That has been done. Your seat is active. Your number is your number. The three hundred and eighty dollars in unapplied credit will be refunded to your account tonight by the controller. I have already told her."
"How much?" Dee said.
"Three hundred and eighty-one dollars and forty-two cents," Whitfield said. "Two quarters and change."
"Okay."
"The club will convene a special meeting of the membership board tomorrow morning at nine, at which Mr. Ashby will be present, and at which the conduct of Mr. Hollis Ellison will be placed on the agenda. I expect we will vote to suspend him from his seat pending a review of every void that has crossed his desk in the past two years. I expect the review to take a month."
"And the person who retyped the form?"
"Will be found," Whitfield said. "That is not a threat to you. That is a statement of fact about how I run this board."
Mara was quiet.
"Ms. Ellison," Whitfield said. "I have one more thing to ask you, and I want you to think about your answer."
"Okay."
"Tomorrow morning at nine, when this goes before the board, do you want to be in the room?"
Mara looked at Dee. Dee looked back. Dee's pen was still.
"Yes," Mara said.
She said it without having to think about it, which was the thing that surprised her, because she had spent three years thinking about the room and about whether she was welcome in it, and she found in this moment that the question had changed shape. It was not *am I welcome in the room.* It was *is the room honest enough for me to be in it.*
"Good," Whitfield said. "Nine o'clock. Bring Ms. Downing's copy of the form and your banking records. Also, if you have it, the chit."
Mara reached into her purse and took out the old brass chit. She placed it on the table on top of the original form.
Whitfield looked at it. He turned it over. He saw the Sunday stamp, nine years old. He saw the member number. He saw the initials at the bottom, in a young man's looped hand.
*D.E.*
"Your brother," he said.
"Yes."
"He signed for a lunch on the family account nine years ago."
"Yes."
"You kept it."
"I didn't know I had it," Mara said. "It was in his wallet. I found it tonight."
Whitfield looked at the chit for a long moment.
"Then the paper that proves the number was his to use," he said, "is a paper he signed himself, and you have been carrying it in a plastic bin in your closet for three years without knowing it." He looked up at her. "Ms. Ellison, I am an old man. I will tell you that I have seen a good deal of what passes for justice at this club. This is about as much of it as I have ever seen assembled in one room."
===
Advertisement
All 8 chapters
- 1The palm landed before the words did.
- 2The parking lot at Willow Bend was laid out like everything else about the club — deliberately. There was the members' row, shaded, close to the door, with brass plaques for the old families. There was the guests' row, in the sun. And the
- 3Serena Downing's email arrived at 4:12. Mara opened it at the red light at the corner of Route 12 and Sunset Boulevard and had to pull into the church parking lot on the far side to actually read it, because there was an attachment, and t
- 4She called Dee.
- 5There was a second signature. There was a president who had known it for eleven weeks. There was a form in the board copy with a field retyped and a form in the membership office with the field intact. There was a chit in the plastic bin
- 6By nine-forty she was outside on the brick path between the clubhouse and the parking lot, standing under the shade of the porte-cochère with Dee beside her and both of them not saying anything.
- 7She did not call her father from the break room. She finished her shift. She drove home. She fed the cat that wasn't really hers — the one that had adopted the duplex — and she sat at her kitchen table with her laptop open and the screens
- 8Tuesday morning at eight forty, Mara pulled into the Willow Bend members' row parking lot and parked in the second spot from the door.





