Chapter 7 : She did not call her father from the break room. She finished her shift. She drove home. She fed the cat that wasn't really hers — the one that had adopted the duplex — and she sat at her kitchen table with her laptop open and the screens
Then she opened her email and wrote to Serena.
*Serena — I need to think about this before I do anything. Can I ask you one more question. On the file-history screenshot, is 'R.ELLISO' the user ID as it appears, or is it truncated?*
The reply came back at 10:12 pm.
*As it appears. Full ID. R.ELLISO. Not RobertEllison, not REllisonSr. Just R.ELLISO. It doesn't match any current staff ID format. It's an old format. Two letters, dot, last name truncated to six. We switched formats four years ago. So that ID hasn't been in use since before I got here, and probably not since before Renata got here.*
*Thank you.*
*Ms. Ellison — are you okay?*
*Yeah.*
*Okay. If you need me to do anything else, text me. I'll be at my desk at 8.*
Mara closed the laptop and walked out onto the small concrete balcony above the garage and stood looking at the street.
She went back inside and called her father.
It was 10:34 on Monday night. He answered on the fourth ring.
"Mara."
"Dad. I need to ask you a question and I need you to answer it without asking me why."
A pause. "Okay."
"Did you ever have a login at the club?"
Silence.
"Dad."
"I don't know what you mean," he said.
"I mean a computer login. An account. For the membership office, or the club's network, or the board's mailing system, or anything. Did you ever have one?"
Another silence. The porch swing creaked.
"Mara," her father said. "Look. I'm going to tell you something and I need you to just listen."
"Okay."
"After your mother died — after, not before — after, I had a login for the club's system. Just for the family seat. Just to pay the dues online, they gave us a login. Your mother always did that, and when she got sick, I asked them to switch it to me, and they did. I paid the dues for a while. Then I got remarried, and Brenda took it over because she likes paying bills online. And then Daniel started paying his own, and he asked me to stop, and I stopped. I think we let it go dormant. I don't know what happened to it. I haven't used it in — I don't know — twelve years."
"Was the login ID R.ELLISO?"
"How would I know that?"
"You'd know if you ever used it."
"Mara, I'd use it once every three months to pay the dues. I'd type the password and hit pay. I don't remember the ID."
"But the ID would have been yours."
"It would have been something like that. It would have been based on my name. But it would have been from the old system."
"And did you ever use it after you got remarried?"
"I don't think so."
"Dad. Did you ever use it in the last two years?"
A long pause.
"I don't know, Mara."
"Dad."
"Mara, I'm telling you I don't know."
"Then who did?"
Silence.
"Dad," Mara said, and her voice did not shake, which was surprising to her, but she had known for the last hour exactly what she was going to have to say, and she had rehearsed it on the balcony with the neighbor's cat watching her from the rail. "Dad, there are two versions of the form on file. One with Mr. Ashby's counter-approval and one without. The version without was made on Friday afternoon at 4:31 at the club's office, and the user ID that made it was R.ELLISO, and R.ELLISO hasn't been an active account in four years. Whoever made the copy used an old login. An old login that would have been yours."
Her father said nothing.
"I'm not accusing you of anything," Mara said. "I want you to hear that. I'm not accusing you. But I need you to think about who had access to your old login at the club. Because if it wasn't you, someone else did. And if it was you — even if you don't remember what you were doing on Friday afternoon at 4:31 — then I need you to tell me now, before nine tomorrow morning, because Mr. Whitfield is going to ask me about it and I am not going to lie to him."
The line was quiet for so long that she looked at her screen to make sure the call hadn't dropped.
"I need to call you back," her father said.
"Dad."
"I need to call you back."
He hung up.
Mara put the phone down on the kitchen table and sat there.
At 10:51 her phone rang. Her father.
"Mara," he said, and his voice was flat now, the way it used to be when he was tired at the end of a school year. "I'm going to tell you what I remember, and then I'm going to tell you what I think, and you can take both to Mr. Whitfield tomorrow, and I'll drive over there with you if you want."
"Okay."
"Back in March, Hollis and I had a conversation. He told me you were still at the club and that the family couldn't afford two seats, and that he was going to file a void on your seat and reassign it to Will, and that he needed me to sign off on it as the eldest living Ellison on the paperwork. I told him I wouldn't sign off on anything that took Daniel's seat away from you without your consent. He told me I didn't have a say. I told him I did have a say, and I told him no."
"Okay."
"He told me he would take care of it without me. I told him to knock himself out. I thought that was the end of it."
"Okay."
"Last Wednesday, Hollis's wife called Brenda, and Brenda called me, and Hollis came over to my house Thursday afternoon to have a beer on the porch. He said he wanted to smooth things over. He said the club was going to have to make a decision about the seat on Friday, and that he needed my help making it clean. I told him I didn't know what clean meant. He said clean meant I needed to log in to the membership system once with my old ID and review the current form in the shared drive, so it would show as 'family member review' in the log. I told him I didn't know how. He sat down on the porch with me and showed me on his own laptop."
"He had your login."
"He had my login. I gave it to him because I didn't know it was still active, and I didn't know what the review field was for, and I trusted him. He told me it was a formality. He told me you'd already been told about the seat. He told me you agreed to it." Her father's voice cracked, once, and steadied. "Mara, I believed him because he's my brother. I believed him because for thirty years he remembered everybody's birthday. I didn't log in. I gave him the login and let him do it because I don't use computers the way he does. And Mara — I'm sorry. That's the whole thing. That's what I gave him. I'm sorry."
Mara closed her eyes.
"Dad," she said, after a while. "Do you remember what time he was at your house Thursday?"
"Two-fifteen. I remember because I had a chiropractor at four and I was worried about the time."
"Okay. Dad, I need you to write it down. Write it in a notebook. Date, time, what he said, what you did. I need you to text me a photograph of what you wrote before you go to bed."
"Okay."
"Dad."
"Yes."
"Thank you for telling me."
Her father did not say anything for a while.
"I should have told you months ago," he said. "I knew, Mara. I knew in my gut when he told me about the seat. I just didn't want to believe. I didn't want to go to that club and ask."
"I know."
"Call me tomorrow," he said. "I'll be by the phone."
===
Advertisement
All 8 chapters
- 1The palm landed before the words did.
- 2The parking lot at Willow Bend was laid out like everything else about the club — deliberately. There was the members' row, shaded, close to the door, with brass plaques for the old families. There was the guests' row, in the sun. And the
- 3Serena Downing's email arrived at 4:12. Mara opened it at the red light at the corner of Route 12 and Sunset Boulevard and had to pull into the church parking lot on the far side to actually read it, because there was an attachment, and t
- 4She called Dee.
- 5There was a second signature. There was a president who had known it for eleven weeks. There was a form in the board copy with a field retyped and a form in the membership office with the field intact. There was a chit in the plastic bin
- 6By nine-forty she was outside on the brick path between the clubhouse and the parking lot, standing under the shade of the porte-cochère with Dee beside her and both of them not saying anything.
- 7She did not call her father from the break room. She finished her shift. She drove home. She fed the cat that wasn't really hers — the one that had adopted the duplex — and she sat at her kitchen table with her laptop open and the screens
- 8Tuesday morning at eight forty, Mara pulled into the Willow Bend members' row parking lot and parked in the second spot from the door.





