Chapter 4
Monday morning at nine, the county assessor's office called her back.
The caller was a woman named Yolanda Herrera, a supervising appraiser, and she wanted to know two things: whether the second camera still existed in a form that could be authenticated, and whether the perimeter fence at 1439 Sandpiper had a permit on file.
"It doesn't," Yolanda said. "I pulled the records this morning. The fence was built in 2021. There's no permit. The pool deck was added in 2022 and the height variance was never filed at the county level."
Maggie closed the kitchen drawer she had been standing at. "So the board's exception—"
"The board's exception means something to the CC&Rs," Yolanda said. "It does not mean anything to the county. If somebody at 1439 built past the setback, that's a separate issue. The reason I'm calling is that we received a request on April seventeenth from the management company for a copy of the exception page. The request was signed by Patricia Vance."
Maggie was quiet.
"She requested her own exception page," Yolanda said. "Four days before the hearing, she asked the county for a copy of a document she had signed, which is what a person does when they're not sure the carbon still exists."
"She was checking whether I still had it."
"I can't speak to that. I can tell you we have the request on file and we're retaining the records. The county attorney's office will be notified if the request looks like it was made in bad faith."
Maggie thanked her and hung up and stood in her kitchen with her hands on the counter.
She had asked the clerk for the carbon on April 4. Pat had asked the county for the exception page on April 17. Between those two dates, Pat had been doing the exact thing Maggie had been doing — trying to find out who held the paper.
And then she had gone to the meeting and called the fine anyway.
Which meant Pat had not known. Which meant the carbon had been hidden well enough that Pat had run the risk on Saturday and lost.
Maggie picked up her phone and texted Dave.
"The April 17 county request was signed by Pat. We can prove she was trying to find the exception three days before the hearing."
His reply came in under a minute.
"Then she didn't know you had the carbon. So the Nextdoor account wasn't created by her."
Maggie put the phone down.
She stood in the kitchen with that for a long time, because it changed the shape of everything.
The Nextdoor account had been created at 9:42 a.m. Saturday — thirteen minutes before the meeting. If Pat Vance had known about the carbon, she would not have called the fine. She would have pulled the agenda item and rescheduled the hearing and quietly declined to enforce it and waited for the heat to die down, which was the strategy any real estate agent would have run in twenty seconds flat.
She had called the fine. She had slammed the ledger and pointed across the room and read the address from the page in her own handwriting. She had not expected the carbon. Which meant somebody else had expected it.
Somebody else had known that Maggie was walking into that room with the document.
The only person on earth who had known was Dana Reyes.
Maggie sat back down at the kitchen table.
It was possible that Dana had made the account herself. It was possible that Dana had told one other person. It was possible that Dana had told somebody at the management company, who had told somebody else, who had been in the room and had opened an account on a phone in the parking lot while Maggie was still sitting in her own car with the air conditioner running.
And the screenshot — the one that had been posted to the home-owners group — had been cropped by somebody who had been standing where the television was visible but the president's face mostly was not, which was the side aisle, which was where Dave Pruitt had walked up.
Maggie picked up her phone again.
"Dave," she texted. "Do you remember who was standing in the side aisle on Saturday when you switched the TV on?"
His reply took four minutes.
"Susan Whitfield was standing behind the coffee urn. Denny Booth was in the second row. Carol Reyes was on the aisle. There was also a man I didn't recognize in the back left corner. He came in late, after the fine was called. Left before the vote."
A man.
Maggie sat with that for a minute. She didn't know anybody who would come to a Saturday morning HOA hearing, sit in the back left corner, and leave before the vote unless they had a reason.
She went to the county property records portal on her laptop and pulled the request log for the exception page again. The April 17 request had been signed by Patricia Vance. But there had been one request before it — on April 8, also from the management company, also for the exception page.
Signed by a person named R. Bell.
Maggie did not know a R. Bell. She typed the name into the community directory and got nothing. She typed it into the management-company email signature directory that Dana had given her on Friday afternoon and got a match.
R. Bell was the regional portfolio manager. He managed eleven HOA accounts in the tri-county area, and the Sandpiper community was on his list.
One request on April 8, from him. Then one on April 17, from Pat. Both for the same page.
Somebody above the board had been asking about her exception page three days before Pat had asked about it.
---
The rest of Monday went by like a slow leak.
Maggie drove to the management office at eleven. She wanted to see Dana face to face, not through text. The office was in a strip plaza between a nail salon and a tax preparer, glass door, gold vinyl lettering, a small cardboard sign taped inside that said NO SOLICITING UNLESS APPOINTMENT. Dana was at the front desk with a stack of violation notices in front of her and a phone receiver against her shoulder. She saw Maggie and held up one finger — a minute — and finished the call, which was about a tree limb near a mailbox on Heron Way.
She hung up and said, "I was afraid you'd come in."
"I needed to ask you something in person."
"Okay." Dana looked at the door behind her, which was closed, and then at the door to the back office, which was also closed. She lowered her voice anyway. "Ask."
"R. Bell."
Dana's face changed. Not a big change. A small one — the mouth, mostly. "Where did you get that name?"
"County request log. April eighth."
Dana was quiet. She looked down at the stack of violation notices, squared the corners on it with both hands, and then looked back up.
"R. Bell is Ron Bell," she said. "He's the regional portfolio manager. He's not supposed to be on our account. Our account has been assigned to Karen Tullis since 2022. He's above her. He only opens a file if a board president asks him to, which is against company policy, but it happens."
"Did he open a file on mine?"
"A small one. I saw the flag on the dashboard on April eighth." Dana touched the mouse on her desk and turned the monitor away from Maggie out of habit, then turned it back. "I'm not supposed to show you any of this."
"I'm not asking you to show me anything."
Dana nodded slowly. "There's an R. Bell file on 1427 Sandpiper. Open it April eighth. Note in it that says 'verify exception page date,' which is not a normal note, because we don't do exception page dates. That's a county thing."
"Verify the date."
"Verify the date." Dana looked at her. "Whose initials are on the exception page in your folder?"
"Pat's."
"Then why would anybody need to verify a date on a page Pat signed?"
Maggie didn't answer, because she didn't know yet.
She walked back out of the office into the heat of the parking lot and sat in her car with the engine off for a while.
On Tuesday she called Marcus Holloway's office number, got voicemail, and left a short message: her name, her address, a request for a callback about an unassigned regional file on her property. She was not sure he would call back. He did, at 4:40 that afternoon.
"Ms. Ellison," he said. "Your name came up in a portfolio review I did last week."
"I'm surprised."
"You shouldn't be. The Sandpiper account has more exception pages in the last eighteen months than the rest of my portfolio combined. That's usually a sign of something."
He asked her to write it all down. She said she would.
She sat up that night at the kitchen table with a legal pad and wrote the whole thing in order — March 14, March 15, March 28, April 4, April 8, April 17, April 19 — and put a line under it.
Under the line she wrote a name she had not written before: *R. Bell.*
And under that: *Why would a regional manager care whether a page was dated March 14 or March 15?*
She circled it and went to bed.
---
Wednesday, she did something she had never done in nineteen years on this street.
She knocked on Carol Reyes's door at 7:15 in the morning and asked to see the April architectural review minutes, because Carol's husband ran the review committee and kept his own copy of every packet.
Carol looked at her for a second with her coffee cup in her hand. "Are you okay, Maggie?"
"I'm fine."
"You're not fine. But come in."
They sat at Carol's kitchen island with the Friday morning sun coming sideways through the blinds, and Carol pulled the April file folder out of the third drawer of the built-in desk by the pantry and set it on the counter between them.
April 8 review meeting. One exception on the agenda. One vote. One signature page.
Maggie read it twice.
The exception page in Carol's file was a photocopy, and the photocopy was dated April 8, which was three weeks after the March meeting, and it was initialed by two people — Pat Vance, and a second set of initials in the review-committee box that belonged to the committee secretary, who had been on the review committee for the whole three years of Pat's term.
"I don't get it," Carol said. "You had the exception approved in March."
"Somebody filed a second exception page in April," Maggie said. "Which means they were trying to make the paperwork look like it came out of the review committee instead of the board."
"Who would do that?"
Maggie looked at the small print at the bottom of the page — *Regional review required* — and then at the initials, which were not Pat's, which were not Carol's husband's, which did not belong to anyone on the committee, which matched the signature line on the county request for April 8.
"Ron Bell," she said, and Carol put down her coffee cup.
That afternoon, Dana texted her three things in a row.
*The R. Bell file was deleted from our dashboard this morning.*
*I have a screenshot.*
*Do you want it?*
Maggie typed back one word.
*Yes.*
Advertisement